Roundtable discussion on Teaching Science and Mathematics in English

Wawasan Open University and SEDAR Institute organised a roundtable discussion on the Education Ministry’s announcement to abolish the policy of Teaching Science and Mathematics in English (PPSMI) starting in 2012.

WOU’s School of Education, Languages and Communications (SELC) dean Assoc Prof Dr Malachi Edwin Vethamani headed the panel discussion, with speakers Prof Dr Kuldip Kaur from Open University Malaysia (OUM), Prof Dr John Arul Phillips from Asia e University (AeU) and Dr Ganakumaran Subramaniam from the Malaysian English Language Teaching Association (MELTA).

SEDAR director-general Khaw Veon Szu (standing) with (seated from left to right) Prof Kuldip, Prof John Arul, Dr Edwin and Dr Ganakumaran.

SEDAR DIRECTOR-GENERAL KHAW VEON SZU (STANDING) WITH (SEATED FROM LEFT TO RIGHT) PROF KULDIP, PROF JOHN ARUL, DR EDWIN AND DR GANAKUMARAN.

Dr Ganakumaran said that although teaching Science and Mathematics in the students’ mother tongue may make the subjects more accessible and allowed better achievement in the subjects, there was possible loss of opportunities from not learning English especially when moving to tertiary education.

A medical professional quoted statistics that out of 1.56 billion Internet users in the world, 465 million use English on the net, and two thirds of the world’s scientists write their research in English and all international forums are conducted in English. He felt the benefits of teaching Science and Mathematics in English were too important to ignore. However a Tamil-medium school representative believed the use of the mother tongue was critical for students to perform well in Science and Mathematics.

Part of the participants at the roundtable discussion.

PART OF THE PARTICIPANTS AT THE ROUNDTABLE DISCUSSION.

A participant remarked that middle-class parents are aware that students educated using English as a primary medium would flourish. He said his law firm rejects local graduates due to low English proficiency, adding middle-class students will have access to English outside of government schools and thus will excel, leaving lower-class students disadvantaged further and widening the economic gap.

The discussion in progress.

THE DISCUSSION IN PROGRESS.

 

Most participants felt that while some may benefit more from the increased opportunities of learning the subjects in English, other students may need to use their mother tongues. Many agreed that the decision to abolish the policy of teaching Science and Mathematics in English was made without adequate consultation from academicians and the public.

WOU Deputy Vice Chancellor Unni Kumaran Menon said the government should listen to the people rather than make policies on their own. He called for a separation of the education policy from political influence, and for the formation of a Commission of Education to oversee educational policies.

Dr U K Menon (right), Khaw (left), and SEDAR deputy director-general Ng Yeen Seen (3rd from right) with the panel speakers.

DR U K MENON (RIGHT), KHAW (LEFT), AND SEDAR DEPUTY DIRECTOR-GENERAL NG YEEN SEEN (3RD FROM RIGHT) WITH THE PANEL SPEAKERS.

A few felt the failure of the policy of teaching Science and Mathematics in English to improve the standard of English was due to poor implementation of the policy rather than the wrong choice of policy. Prof Kuldip lamented on the poor quality of teaching in Malaysia and the need for better education standards and implementation.

Prof John Arul said the quality of education was a more important issue than the actual choice of language of instruction. He reminded that the primary purpose of teaching Science and Mathematics in English was not to improve English standards, but to allow better access to the fields of Science and Mathematics which see ongoing research and developments in English.

About 30 people, including from the academia, schools, NGOs and the government sector, attended the roundtable discussion.

 

Share:

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn
Share on whatsapp
WhatsApp

Post a comment

Your email address will not be published.

On Key

Related Posts

Natasha Goh
Posted by Natasha Goh
May 17, 2022

Develop your Personal Branding for Greater Reach on LinkedIn

You should know your Social Selling Index (SSI)...

Read More
admin@wou
Posted by admin@wou
May 10, 2022

VC: Make Lifelong Connections at University

Making lifelong friendships and lifelong networks are very...

Read More
admin@wou
Posted by admin@wou
May 9, 2022

WOU Donates Computers to Phor Tay High School for Education

WOU donated 10 refurbished desktop computers to Phor...

Read More
Natasha Goh
Posted by Natasha Goh
May 5, 2022

Making Meaningful Connections: Foundation of Successful Sales

Understanding what is important for your clientele and...

Read More
Natasha Goh
Posted by Natasha Goh
April 25, 2022

Increase your market value as a Certified Project Manager

Employers around the world are looking for certified...

Read More
Natasha Goh
Posted by Natasha Goh
April 14, 2022

Achieve Your Web Developer Dream with a WOU Degree

Web development is an important facet of any...

Read More
Natasha Goh
Posted by Natasha Goh
April 11, 2022

Education is Key to Understand and Support People with HIV/AIDS

Inadequate knowledge and awareness of HIV/AIDS is an...

Read More
Natasha Goh
Posted by Natasha Goh
April 11, 2022

Applying Literature to Engage Learners with Creative Activities

For students to be motivated to participate in...

Read More
admin@wou
Posted by admin@wou
April 11, 2022

Becoming a Sought-after Technical Expert, after WOU

The technical skills and qualifications derived from WOU’s...

Read More
admin@wou
Posted by admin@wou
April 8, 2022
Natasha Goh
Posted by Natasha Goh
March 24, 2022

Understanding Children with Learning Disability in Mathematics

Dyscalculia is not as well-known as dyslexia, and...

Read More
admin@wou
Posted by admin@wou
March 23, 2022

People Can Overcome Depression to Lead Impactful Lives, Says Psychologist

People can battle depression and lead successful and...

Read More
We use cookies to give you the best experience.